11.5 Advertising’s Influence on Culture

Mannequins adorned with "Sale" signs.
Source: Jonathan McIntosh, Mall culture jakarta36, CC BY 2.0.

Advertising’s Influence on Culture

The debate over advertising’s influence on culture is a classic “chicken or the egg” scenario: does advertising merely reflect existing cultural trends, or does it actively shape them? In reality, both ideas hold merit. Advertising acts as a cultural mirror, but the mirror is often a funhouse variety—it selects, amplifies, and distorts specific values to align them with a consumer culture.

Advertising and the Rise of Consumer Culture

George Babbitt, the protagonist of Sinclair Lewis’s 1922 novel Babbitt, truly believed in the growing American consumer culture:

Just as the priests of the Presbyterian Church determined his every religious belief, so did the national advertisers shape the surface of his life, altering what he believed to be his individuality. These standard advertised wares—toothpastes, socks, tires, cameras, instantaneous hot-water heaters—were his symbols and proofs of excellence; at first the signs, and then the substitutes, for joy and passion and wisdom.

This fictional account captured a very real historical transition: the birth of the American consumer.

During this era, automobile ads stopped selling engines and started selling freedom. Simultaneously, advertisers began breaking social taboos to create new markets. By transforming bad breath from a minor social nuisance into the medicalized epidemic of halitosis, Listerine commercials made public discussion of the body acceptable while heightening social anxiety. This era proved that advertising could create needs by redefining cultural standards of hygiene and social acceptance.

Creating the Modern World

Vintage Coca-Cola ad.
Source: Coca-Cola inc., Coca-Cola ad – 1912-05, public domain.

By the mid-20th century, advertising had become the primary architect of the modern American dream. Following World War I, advertising was increasingly viewed as a tool for social engineering. In an address to the American Association of Advertising Agencies in 1926, President Coolidge went as far as to hold advertisers responsible for the “regeneration and redemption of mankind.” In the 1950s and early 60s, agencies—largely staffed by affluent White men—propagated a sanitized, suburban ideal. Shows like Leave It to Beaver and the commercials that surrounded them created a standard of the American family that was almost exclusively White, middle-class, and patriarchal.

However, the cultural backlash of the 1960s forced advertisers to pivot. Instead of ignoring the rebellion, they co-opted it. When Volkswagen marketed the Beetle with the “Think Small” campaign, they turned the era’s anti-consumerist sentiment into a new set of consumer symbols. They proved that even rebellion could be packaged and sold.

The Power of Cultural Symbols: From Apple to Generation X

Apple MacIntosh computer.
Apple’s iconic “1984” commercial framed the launch of the Macintosh computer as a revolutionary act against totalitarian conformity, establishing a bold new standard for cinematic event advertising. Source: All About Apple,  Macintosh 128k transparency, CC BY-SA 2.5 IT

One of the most significant examples of advertising defining a product through cultural trends is Apple’s “1984” Super Bowl commercial. Directed by Ridley Scott, the ad utilized imagery from George Orwell’s dystopian novel to frame the Macintosh not as a computer, but as a weapon against conformity and Big Brother (represented by the industry giant IBM). Apple didn’t just sell a machine; they sold a pioneer identity.

In his study of advertising’s cultural impact, The Conquest of Cool, Thomas Franks compares the advertising of the 1960s with that of the early 1990s:

How [advertisers] must have rejoiced when the leading minds of the culture industry announced the discovery of an all-new angry generation, the “Twenty-Somethings,” complete with a panoply of musical styles, hairdos, and verbal signifiers ready-made to rejuvenate advertising’s sagging credibility…. The strangest aspect of what followed wasn’t the immediate onslaught of even hipper advertising, but that the entire “Generation X” discourse repeated…the discussions of youth culture that had appeared in Advertising Age, Madison Avenue, and on all those youth-market panel discussions back in the sixties.

Advertisers have not set out to consciously manipulate the public in the name of consumer culture. Instead, advertisers perform their job, one that has had an enormous influence on culture.

Advertising Stereotypes and the Visual Language of Perfection

The composition of advertising agencies has historically dictated whose stories are told and how they are visualized. For decades, a predominantly White, middle-class workforce in Madison Avenue agencies created a standard American image that often ignored or caricatured minority populations. However, as social movements gained momentum, the industry began a slow, sometimes painful transition toward more authentic representation.

Breaking the “Mainstream” Mold

"You don't have to be Jewish" ad from Levy's.
Source: Photo on rawpixel, CC0 1.0.

In the 1960s, the Doyle Dane Bernbach agency—famous for its innovative Volkswagen work—began to challenge the industry’s ethnic blind spot. Their campaign for Levy’s Rye Bread featured the headline “You don’t have to be Jewish to love Levy’s,” accompanied by photos of people of various races and ethnicities enjoying the product. This was revolutionary; it transformed ethnic diversity from something to be ignored into a primary selling point. Brands are increasingly responding to these insights. Recent examples of inclusive advertising include Mattel‘s initiative to make its games colorblind-accessible, Amped Fitness‘s creation of Babe Cave women-only gym spaces, and Dove‘s “The Code” campaign, which highlighted the damaging impact of AI-generated images on female confidence. Nike‘s black-and-white spot during Super Bowl LIX, featuring diverse female athletes, also aimed to defy stereotypes and resonate with a broader audience. These efforts reflect a growing understanding that authentic and diverse representation is not just a social imperative but a strategic business advantage that fosters deeper connections with consumers and drives growth.

From Servants to Professionals: Racial Stereotypes

Old Aunt Jemima ad for pancake flour.
Aunt Jemima was rebranded and discontinued its original logo and name. Source: Davis Milling Company, New-York Tribune, November 07, 1909, Page 20, Image 44. Aunt Jemima, public domain.

Before the Civil Rights Movement, African Americans were largely invisible in advertising except when portrayed in domestic roles. Icons such as Aunt Jemima, the Cream of Wheat chef, and Uncle Ben became famous not for their achievements, but as symbols of servitude. By the 1960s, civil rights leaders began meeting with the American Association of Advertising Agencies to protest these biases. While this led to the hiring of more Black employees and the rise of Black-owned agencies in the 1970s, modern data show that disparities remain. In 2023, Hispanic/Latino and Black individuals remained underrepresented within the marketing profession compared to their share of the total U.S. population, while Asian representation was slightly above the national average.

Recent studies, such as those by the Unstereotype Alliance, show that inclusive advertising is not just a social goal but a business imperative. Campaigns that authentically portray a full range of people deliver 3.5% higher short-term sales and a staggering 16% higher long-term sales. Research also indicates that diverse representation in ads can positively influence purchase intent across consumer groups, suggesting that authenticity and broad appeal resonate.

The Gendered Gaze and the Domestic Housewife

Ad with headline "She'll be happier with a Hoover" showing a woman caressing her vacuum cleaner.
Mid-twentieth-century advertisements targeting domestic housewives heavily leveraged traditional gender roles and consumer anxiety, framing household appliances and cleaning products as essential tools for proving maternal devotion and domestic efficiency. Source: James Vaughan, …happier with a Hoover, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0.

Historically, women were the primary targets of advertising because they made approximately 70-80% of consumer purchases. Despite this, early ads placed them in incredibly narrow roles. In the 1960s, women were almost exclusively shown performing domestic chores. In ads targeted at men, women were often portrayed in submissive or hyper-sexualized roles, such as the infamous 1970s National Car Rental ad featuring a disheveled woman with the tagline “Go Ahead, Take Advantage of Us.” Another advertisement from the era pictured a man standing on top of a woman to promote slacks, claiming “it’s nice to have a girl around the house.”

An advertising profile printed in Advertising Age magazine gave a typical advertiser’s understanding of the housewife at the time:

She enjoys watching TV but doesn’t read much. She is most easily reached through TV and the simple, down-to-earth magazines…. Mental activity is arduous for her…. She is a person who wants to have things she can believe in rather than things she can think about.

The National Organization for Women fought back in the early 1970s, protesting offensive billboards and demanding that networks stop treating the housewife as someone for whom mental activity is arduous. While women now make up 67.2% of the marketing workforce and hold over half of senior leadership positions, on-screen representation in high-profile events like the Super Bowl still leans male, with men accounting for 61% of performers in 2023 commercials.

Adobe Photoshop screenshot of the program editing a photograph of a watermelon.
Adobe Photoshop fundamentally revolutionized the advertising industry by making digital photo manipulation fast and widely accessible, enabling marketers to create hyper-polished imagery while simultaneously raising enduring cultural debates over digital realism, deceptive beauty standards, and ethical disclosure. Source: Screenshot: Own work Photograph: Frederic Eugene Ives (1856–1937), Photoshop-screenshot, public domain.

The Impact of Adobe Photoshop: The Digital Ideal

The 1990 launch of Adobe Photoshop fundamentally changed the visual language of persuasion. By digitizing the workflow, Photoshop allowed advertisers to create hyper-idealized, perfect versions of reality. Models could now have digitally smoothed skin, cinched waists, and altered features that were impossible to achieve in real life. While this gave creators immense artistic power, it also ushered in significant negative consequences, particularly concerning the perpetuation of unrealistic beauty standards and their impact on mental health.

Constant exposure to digitally sculpted bodies has been linked to increased body dissatisfaction and eating disorders, particularly among younger audiences who compare themselves to fabricated images. This widespread digital alteration can blur the lines between reality and fantasy, fostering a sense of inadequacy. Furthermore, excessive manipulation has raised ethical concerns about truthfulness, prompting countries such as France and Norway to require that advertisements disclose when images have been digitally altered. Brands are increasingly responding to these insights by prioritizing unretouched imagery to foster deeper connections with consumers.

Child watching television.
Source: Alec Couros, In the Glow, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0.

Advertising to Children

The landscape of advertising to children has undergone a significant transformation, yet core challenges persist. Traditionally, most advertisements targeting children featured either toys or junk food. A fundamental concern, still relevant today, is that children under eight often struggle to distinguish between fantasy and reality, a vulnerability that some advertisers have historically exploited. Studies continue to show that a high percentage of food advertisements aimed at children promote high-calorie, low-nutritional value foods, such as sugary cereals, contributing to concerns about childhood obesity.

While governments and self-regulatory bodies have long sought to regulate this area, the proliferation of digital media has introduced more subtle marketing tactics. Online video games, known as advergames, remain a prominent example, offering children immersive periods of product exposure. Beyond these games, digital tactics include:

In response to these evolving tactics, the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act was updated with a final rule in early 2025. These new regulations require separate parental opt-in consent for targeted advertising and impose strict limits on data retention. Additionally, the Children’s Advertising Review Unit continues to monitor child-directed media across all platforms, including the Metaverse and AI applications, to ensure age-appropriate messaging.

As children’s media consumption has shifted from television to social platforms, the rise of kid-fluencers—minors who review toys or vlogs about their daily lives—has created a new ethical frontier. Many states have introduced legislation modeled after the Coogan Laws to ensure that child digital creators are protected from financial exploitation by their guardians. These laws require a percentage of advertising earnings to be set aside in a trust for the child and mandate strict limits on work hours. This reflects a broader cultural shift toward recognizing that when a child’s play becomes a primary driver of multi-million-dollar advertising campaigns, they deserve the same labor protections as traditional child actors.

Positive Effects of Advertising

Despite many focusing on the adverse outcomes, the medium has provided unique benefits over time. Early newspaper advertising allowed publications to become independent of church and government control, encouraging a free press capable of criticizing powerful interests. When the media transitioned to an advertising model, these publications became accessible to a larger audience who previously could not afford them. This model also supported the golden ages of radio and television in each medium’s infancy, when advertisers participated heavily in program production.

Advertising also makes newer forms of media both practical and accessible. Many internet services, such as email and smartphone applications, appear free because they are supported by advertising revenue. This allows lower-income classes to participate in mass culture by eliminating upfront purchase prices. Furthermore, advertising has promoted the arts throughout its history; where painters once relied on wealthy patrons, corporate advertising now provides artists and musicians with new means to fund their creative endeavors and gain public notoriety.

Changing Standards of Advertisements

Cigarette ad that says "Blow in her face and she will follow you anywhere."
Tipalet’s late-1960s cigarette advertising campaign became a textbook example of overt vintage sexism by suggesting that flavored tobacco smoke possessed seductive power over women. Source: Mid-Century Press, Tipalet Cigarettes – Blow in her face, CC BY-NC 2.0.

Advertising standards are dynamic reflections of societal values and ethical considerations, evolving significantly over time. Examining past ads offers a stark illustration of how our collective understanding of gender roles, race, and health has evolved. For instance, a 1950s print ad for Schlitz beer depicted a man comforting a woman holding a frying pan with burnt food with the tagline “Don’t worry, darling, you didn’t burn the beer!” This ad, designed to reinforce traditional domestic roles, would be widely criticized today for its demeaning portrayal of women.

Another deeply problematic area in historical advertising is the pervasive use of racist tropes. In the early 20th century, brands like Aunt Jemima and Uncle Ben’s used imagery rooted in problematic racial stereotypes, often depicting Black individuals in subservient roles. These practices are now widely recognized as unacceptable and damaging. Similarly, tobacco companies used to run campaigns directly linking smoking to positive attributes like sophistication, vitality, and even good health, with slogans such as “More Doctors Smoke Camels.” Ads for Lucky Strike cigarettes even suggested smoking could help women stay slender. These claims, now legally prohibited in many contexts and utterly disproven, illustrate a complete disregard for public health that would be considered grossly irresponsible and unethical today. These examples show that advertising standards are closely tied to changing laws and a stronger commitment to ethical responsibility.

In the modern marketplace, advertising has become a primary vehicle for communicating a brand’s commitment to Environmental, Social, and Governance principles. Modern consumers increasingly view their purchases as votes for the kind of world they want to inhabit, forcing advertisers to move beyond simple product features toward values-based storytelling. While this has encouraged many brands to adopt more sustainable practices, it has also fostered a culture of heightened scrutiny. Advertisements that tout environmental or social progress are now regularly fact-checked by global audiences in real-time, making corporate transparency a non-negotiable standard for cultural relevance.

Algorithmic Culture and Social Proof

The influence of advertising on culture has moved beyond direct persuasion into the realm of algorithmic culture. Through artificial intelligence, digital platforms amplify specific trends, sounds, and aesthetics, creating a sense of social proof that dictates what is considered popular or desirable. This means that advertising no longer tells a consumer what to buy; it shapes the very cultural environment they inhabit by ensuring that certain viral brand moments appear everywhere at once. In this ecosystem, the line between a genuine cultural trend and a calculated advertising maneuver is increasingly thin, as algorithms prioritize content that keeps users engaged with brand-adjacent lifestyles.

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

Understanding Media and Culture 2026 Copyright © 2026 by North Idaho College is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.